Candy Sandwiches

1B31C506-E2E7-465E-B732-B0DB639D6E91

What is every preschooler’s food fantasy?

My grandson’s was a candy sandwich.


The Birth of the Concept

We are blessed with the most adorable Irish twins – ages 4 and 5. They were born one year apart with January birthdays.

A couple of months ago, while visiting them, my step-daughter Jenn asked what kind of sandwiches they wanted for lunch, and my older grandson replied, “a candy sandwich!”

That got me thinking (way too hard). I told my son-in-law, that challah bread would be perfect for candy sandwiches. He agreed, as he had recently seen a Food Network show with stuffed challah French toast.

Bread Snob

To be honest, I am a total bread snob. If it’s sliced, I probably won’t buy it. I am into fancy artisan loafs. When I was young and ambitious, I used to bake my own bread.

So, on my grandson’s 4th birthday, I put together the plan. I sent my husband to the best Jewish bakery in Las Vegas: Bagel Cafe. We go there at least monthly for breakfast, and we stop in every few weeks for bagels. Their rugalah and bobkas are also amazing.

88C4CE6C-F330-4C9F-BF4C-156BE75DB3A8
Bagel Cafe: Everything Bagel & Lox

We arranged to meet Jenn and the boys at their nearby grocery store, where we picked up marshmallow cream and Oreo cookies. The boys selected candy for their sandwiches: gummy bears, sour gummy worms, watermelon candies, jelly beans, and gum drops. I already had chocolate syrup and Christmas cookie sprinkles, and Jenn had peanut butter.

F7FAEE31-275B-4520-893C-02568B1FA0D7
Candy Sandwich Ingredients

The Process

I sliced the bread and helped the boys make it into circles using cookie cutters. Then I lightly toasted the circles to make spreading a little easier.

FE802C1D-A3DE-4E8E-8087-C8630008926C

My husband grated the Oreo cookies to make cookie “dirt.”

0F272E0F-C0E8-4B66-A95C-BDBFF939CD9C

The boys spread the peanut butter, marshmallow cream, and chocolate syrup in various combinations onto the circles.

E082FFEA-F8F7-4E32-9015-D822F11BF123

Next, they decorated their open-faced sandwiches with cookie dirt and candy.

9192AAA7-AF86-46E7-A17D-3F82B0D49BFA

The entire process – aside from shopping – took about 30 minutes, and the boys had a great time!

8D5884F2-A24D-47BA-A3AA-A9F0FC63B90E
Final Product!

This would be a great birthday party activity!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s